Troublesome will

Troublesome will
In this post I want to bring a mathematical puzzle. If you think you have a high I.Q. you can test yourself with this puzzle.
In former times 3 sons received some horses from the inheritance of their father. Before his death he willed that the first son would receive one second, his second son would receive one third and the last son would receive one ninth of the horses. But the problem was that after the death of the old man the number of the horses was 17 and their divisions seemed impossible according their father's will.
Now, can u solve this problem? Remember that your solution should be convincing.
Imam Ali the leader of us who are Shiites solved this problem more than 1400 years ago.
We will postpone introducing Imam Ali until later. But you can read the interesting answer to this puzzle in the comment part of this post.
Please think about it before you look at the answer of the puzzle.

8 comments:

Unknown said...

For solving this problem imam Ali added his own horse to their horses, so the number of horses became 18 and according to their father's will, the first son received 9 horses (one half), the second son received 6 horses (one third) and the last son received 2 horses (one ninth) and a horse remained out of 18 and it belonged to imam Ali. Imam Ali withdrew
his own horse and in conformity with their father's will he could divide the horses fairly among the sons.
Had you managed to solve that puzzle?

Anonymous said...

excellent.
good luck.
(Ghazalak)

Mehmet said...

interesting.. I couldnt come to that idea :D

Salam Mostafa

ahfy said...

hi
you know me?
think?
think more my brother
ok i say
do you remmeber this blog
www.invitetoislam.persianblog.com
?
i use your usefull comment and i start to make another blog
www.cuteislam.blogfa.com
and need your usefull comments more
ok?
have good time
"khodahafez"

Sababoy said...

صبح سپید امروز در عرفان شعله فانوس تو آغاز شد. پرنده ای آواز آغاز بهار خواند و من از شعر حافظ دگرباره صبح را زنده شدم.

Morning started white, today in red gnostic of your lantern flame. A bird sung starting of spring and I was freshened from Hafez poem in the morning

Mehmet said...

do you mean me?

محک said...

You need a horse to the added 11 hp 12 hp between now this is split into boys
(Of course camel Old books are listed)

Hoor said...

Imam Ali is very great..
He is so intelligent..
I like his character so much.. and I like to read about him...

Thank you, brother, for this topic..

kind regards,
Hoor